通鉴抉择 · 这一题,你会怎么选

如果你是王莽,你怎么做?

新 · 王莽始建国二年

始建国二年,陈良、终带在边郡起事,自称「废汉大将军」,事败后逃入匈奴。又有人拦车自称成帝遗腹子刘子舆,扬言刘氏当复。立国将军请罢掉长安城里的汉家宗庙,并免去刘姓官员。庙在,汉的名分就还在;一诏废庙,则四百年祭祀断绝。王莽要不要准。

选好之后,再看史书怎么记。

Records of the Grand Historian — 究天人之际

The phrase *jiu tian ren zhi ji, tong gu jin zhi bian*—“to fathom the relation between Heaven and humanity, to comprehend change across past and present”—captures the intellectual ambition at the heart of the *Records of the Grand Historian*. It appears in the “Grand Historian’s Own Preface,” where Sima Qian explains why he undertook this vast historical project: not merely to record events, but to discern patterns linking celestial phenomena, human conduct, and political order. The excerpts show how closely the text ties natural signs—lunar eclipses, retrograde stars, solar halos, winds—to moral and administrative realities: “since the Zhou declined, human affairs grew chaotic, and thus heavenly phenomena changed in response.” Such passages treat astronomy not as abstract science but as a responsive mirror of governance—where the “Azure Emperor’s” virtuous rule opens the “Heavenly Gate,” and the “Red Emperor’s” virtue empties the “Heavenly Prison.” To “fathom Heaven-human relations” means reading these correlations seriously; to “comprehend change across time” means tracing how such correspondences unfold from antiquity to Sima Qian’s own era. This is history as moral cosmology: rigorous, observant, and deeply concerned with how human choices reverberate through the fabric of the cosmos. The *Records of the Grand Historian* thus invites readers not just to learn what happened, but to consider how heaven, earth, and humanity hold each other in dynamic, consequential balance.

SourcesOriginal passages and citations
  • 史記

    月蚀及星逆行,非太平之常。自周衰以来,人事多乱,故天文应之遂变耳。」骃案:孟康曰「晕,日旁气也。 ,日之将食,先有黑气之变」。〉 风,